Updated: 12/11/2013 16:44 | By Agence France-Presse

India's top court reinstates ban on gay sex

India's Supreme Court reinstated a colonial-era ban on gay sex on Wednesday that could see homosexuals jailed for up to 10 years in a major setback for rights campaigners in the world's biggest democracy.


India's top court reinstates ban on gay sex

India's Supreme Court has reinstated a colonial-era ban on gay sex that could see homosexuals jailed for up to 10 years in a major setback for rights campaigners in the world's biggest democracy

A two-judge bench struck down a Delhi High Court ruling in 2009 that section 377 of the Indian penal code prohibiting "carnal acts against the order of nature" infringed the fundamental rights of Indians.

The landmark ruling four years ago emboldened the still largely closeted gay community which has since campaigned publicly against widespread discrimination and ignorance.

But a two-judge Supreme Court bench headed by G.S. Singhvi, who will retire on Thursday, found that the High Court had overstepped and that the law against gay sex was constitutionally valid.

"It is up to parliament to legislate on this issue," Singhvi said in the judgement which crushed the hopes of activists who had fought the case and led to tears outside the court.

The 2009 High Court decision was strongly opposed by religious groups, particularly leaders of India's Muslim and Christian communities, who appealed to the Supreme Court.

"Such a decision was totally unexpected from the top court. It is a black day for the community," Arvind Narayan, a lawyer of the Alternative Law Forum gay rights group, told reporters outside court.

"We are very angry about this regressive decision of the court," he added.

Rights campaign group Amnesty International said the ruling was a "body blow to people’s rights to equality, privacy and dignity", while a legal challenge from gay rights groups is also likely.

"We will explore all options, probably look into the option of a review petition," T. Tandon, a lawyer appearing for Naz Foundation, a non-profit group that works with HIV-AIDS patients, said outside the court house.

"The movement of gay rights is so much stronger now. It is not 2001, it is 2013. You can't have a decision like this."

While protests were expected later in New Delhi and Mumbai, religious groups who appealed the decision were delighted with the outcome.

"We know that homosexuality is against nature," general secretary of the All India Muslim Personal Law Board, Abdul Raheem Quraishi, told AFP.

"It goes against all its laws and it is what led to the spread of HIV/AIDS," he added.

The United Nations Development Programme on HIV/AIDS had argued in 2008 that decriminalising homosexuality would help India to combat the spread of HIV/AIDS which affects an estimated 2.5 million people.

Dominic Emmanuel, spokesman of the Delhi Catholic Archdiocese, said before the verdict that the church was ready to accept any decision even though it opposed homosexuality.

"The church has a very clear stand on people with different sexual orientations. Though they are different from ... normal people, they should be respected, accepted and there should be no signs of discrimination against them," he told NDTV network.

Gay sex has long been a taboo subject in conservative India, where homophobic tendencies abound and many still regard being gay as a mental illness.

In recent years, however, the country's gay community has raised its profile through gay pride marches, magazines and events which have created awareness and encouraged many to come out of the closet.

The country has no major gay public figures in politics, entertainment or sport.

The decision from the powerful Supreme Court puts India back in the company of most nations in the Islamic world and many African countries which criminalise homosexuality.

"It is highly embarrassing for the country because now we will be among the dirty dozens of the world," said Narayan, the lawyer from the Alternative Law Forum.

In most western countries, the debate about gay rights has shifted on to same-sex marriage with more than a dozen countries allowing homosexual couples to wed.

"The judgement is astounding," said Parmesh Shahani, author of "Gay Bombay: Globalization, Love and (Be)longing in Contemporary India."

"If you read the High Court judgement -- which was incredibly progressive and intelligently worded -- it said the state had no business in interfering with who private citizens choose to love."

Latest Photo Galleries on xinmsn

NEWS VIDEOS

MORE NEWS VIDEOS

facebook recommendations

LIVE NEWS RADIO STREAMING

  • 938 Live

    938LIVE is Singapore's only English news and talk station which transmits round the clock with an engaging and enticing spread of programmes on current affairs, health, business and lifestyle as well as news every half hour until midnight.

  • Capital 958


    95.8FM城市频道的前身是"第三广播网"。上个世纪30年代末,新加坡就有中文广播,一路走来经过不少政治,社会局势的改变,中文广播在本地一直扮演举足轻重的角色。